Why Mutual Funds Are Overrated (But Vital)

Understanding the Basics of Mutual Funds

Mutual funds pool money from various investors and invest it in stocks, bonds, gold, or other securities. A professional fund manager oversees this pooled corpus, aiming to achieve the fund's objectives—be it growth, income, or stability.

Mutual funds are categorized into several types:

1. Equity Funds: Focused on stocks, offering higher returns but higher risks.
2. Debt Funds: Invest in fixed-income securities, offering stability and moderate returns.
3. Hybrid Funds: Blend equity and debt for balanced risk and reward.
4. Sectoral/Thematic Funds: Focus on specific sectors or themes, such as technology or infrastructure.
5. Index Funds/ETFs: Track indices like Nifty50 or Sensex, offering passive investment options.

With over ₹46 trillion assets under management (AUM) in India (as of 2024), mutual funds have become a go-to option for individuals looking for diversification and convenience.

5 Key Points to Evaluate Before Selecting Mutual Fund Schemes

Before diving in, here are the five critical factors to ensure you’re choosing the best mutual fund schemes:

1. Investment Objective and Time Horizon
   Align the mutual fund’s objective with your financial goals. For instance, equity funds are ideal for long-term wealth creation, while debt funds suit short-term liquidity needs.
2. Fund Performance vs. Benchmark
   Don’t just look at past returns in isolation. Compare the fund’s performance against its benchmark index (e.g., Nifty50) over a 3-, 5-, and 10-year horizon. Avoid funds that consistently underperform their benchmarks.
3. Expense Ratio
   The expense ratio represents the cost of managing the fund. Lower expense ratios are preferable as they leave more room for net returns. For example, index funds typically have expense ratios under 1%, while actively managed funds can go up to 2.5%.
4. Consistency Over Fluctuations
   Instead of chasing the highest returns, look for consistency. A fund that delivers 12–15% annualized returns steadily is better than one oscillating wildly between 5% and 25%.
5. Portfolio Diversification
   Ensure the fund is not overly concentrated in one sector or a few stocks. Diversification reduces risk, particularly during market downturns.

Past Performance: Mutual Funds vs. Equities, Gold, and Property
Let’s address the elephant in the room: How do mutual funds fare compared to other popular investment avenues in India?

• Equities: Between 2014–2024, Indian equity mutual funds (large-cap funds) delivered average annualized returns of ~11%, closely tracking the performance of indices like Nifty50. Direct equity investments can outperform, but they come with higher risks and require expertise.
• Gold: Gold ETFs yielded an annualized return of ~6–8% over the same period, proving to be a reliable hedge during economic uncertainties.
• Property: Real estate investments saw an annual growth of ~5–7% in Tier-I cities, but they suffer from illiquidity and high transaction costs.
• Fixed Deposits/Debt Funds: Traditional FDs offered ~6–7% annually, while debt mutual funds slightly outpaced them with returns of ~7–9%.

Mutual funds offer a balanced approach, often outperforming gold and property while being less volatile than direct equities.

Mistakes to Avoid While Investing in Mutual Funds

Despite their advantages, investors often make these common errors, undermining their potential gains:

1. Chasing Recent Top Performers
   Many investors invest in funds that recently delivered stellar returns, ignoring that past performance doesn’t guarantee future success.
2. Ignoring Risk Appetite
   Investing in high-risk funds (e.g., small-cap or sectoral funds) without assessing personal risk tolerance leads to panic-selling during market corrections.
3. Lack of Financial Goals
   Investing randomly without clear objectives (e.g., retirement or child’s education) results in mismatched expectations and poor decision-making.
4. Overlooking Costs
   High expense ratios, exit loads, and taxation on short-term capital gains can erode returns significantly.
5. Skipping Research
   Blindly following friends, family, or influencers without understanding the fund’s strategy, asset allocation, or manager’s expertise often ends in disappointment.
6. Inconsistent Investment Approach
   Many investors stop SIPs (Systematic Investment Plans) during market downturns, missing out on the opportunity to average costs and maximize long-term gains.

Factual Insights: Indian Mutual Fund Market 2024

• SIP contributions hit an all-time high of ₹16,000 crore monthly in 2024, reflecting growing trust among retail investors.
• Over 60% of AUM is concentrated in equity funds, indicating the rising popularity of wealth-building options.
• Data shows that long-term investors (5+ years) in equity mutual funds consistently beat inflation and fixed deposit returns.

Conclusion

Mutual funds, like any investment, come with their own set of risks and rewards. By focusing on objective evaluation criteria, understanding their performance in comparison to other asset classes, and avoiding common mistakes, you can make the most of what mutual funds have to offer. While reverse psychology suggests reasons to not invest in mutual funds, the reality is that they remain one of the most versatile and accessible tools for wealth creation, particularly for investors willing to play the long game.

So, are mutual funds really not for you? Or is it time to rethink your strategy?

Explore more insightful content on Daanik Blogs.